The Library
BMC PUBLIC HEALTH · Employee Engagement

Toxic leadership and employee health: exploring psychosocial stress pathways in organizational settings

Not yet classifiedby Megren Abdullah AltassanAugust 3, 2026 34 min read
toxic leadership psychosocial stress employee wellbeing organisational culture power distance saudi arabia hr effectiveness qualitative research leadership development mental health at work

Editorial summary. This is our text summary of an article. Charts, figures, and the author’s full voice are at the original — read it there .

Licence. The original is licensed under CC BY 4.0. This page adapts it: the summary and analysis are ours, not the authors’.

Editorial verdict

Methodologically transparent qualitative study with meaningful cultural insights, but single-author design, English-only interviews in an Arabic-speaking context, and unequal sector sampling limit the depth and representativeness of findings — treat themes as directionally informative rather than definitive.

Executive summary

This qualitative study examines how toxic leadership affects the psychological and occupational well-being of employees in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, addressing a recognised gap in leadership research within Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) and broader Middle Eastern organisational contexts. The author argues that high power distance, collectivist values, religious norms, and informal influence networks (wasta) shape how employees experience, internalise, and respond to harmful supervisory behaviours in culturally specific ways that Western quantitative instruments fail to capture. Drawing on 42 semi-structured interviews across healthcare, business, and education sectors, thematic analysis produced seven themes: Silent Suffering; Cultural Rationalization of Abuse; Emotional and Mental Drain; Coping Strategies and Resistance; Leadership as Untouchable Power; Organizational Silence and HR Inaction; and Normalization and Identity Conflict. Findings are interpreted through the Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) model, Conservation of Resources (COR) theory, and Social Exchange Theory, contextualised within Saudi cultural dynamics. The study concludes that structural accountability, culturally aligned leadership development, independent grievance mechanisms, and accessible mental health support are necessary responses to toxic leadership in Saudi workplaces, particularly during the organisational transformation associated with Vision 2030.

researchRelevance: 7/10Middle East

Key insights

  • 1Cultural constructs including wasta, hierarchical deference, and religious frameworks for enduring hardship (sabr) function as mechanisms that normalise toxic leadership and suppress employee voice in Saudi organisational settings.
  • 2HR departments were widely perceived as extensions of management rather than neutral employee advocates, with complaints frequently ignored or dismissed, producing institutional cynicism and discouraging future reporting.
  • 3Psychosomatic symptoms — including insomnia, migraines, chest pain, and panic attacks — were commonly reported alongside psychological effects such as burnout, emotional numbness, and identity erosion, indicating that toxic leadership produces both mental and physical health consequences.

Practical takeaways

  • Organisations in high power-distance, collectivist contexts may need independently operated, confidential reporting channels (such as ombudsperson services or third-party hotlines) rather than relying on internal HR processes that employees perceive as structurally compromised.
  • Leadership development programmes in culturally specific contexts may gain credibility and uptake by grounding ethical leadership competencies in indigenous values (such as Islamic principles of rahmah, 'adl, and amanah) rather than applying Western behavioural frameworks without adaptation.

Frameworks mentioned

Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) Model

A model conceptualising how job demands deplete employee resources and how job resources buffer stress; used in this study to interpret how toxic leadership constitutes a primary demand driving burnout and emotional exhaustion.

Conservation of Resources (COR) Theory

A theory proposing that stress arises from the loss or threat of loss of valued personal resources; applied here to explain how toxic leadership depletes employees' emotional energy, dignity, and identity.

Social Exchange Theory

A framework explaining workplace relationships as reciprocal exchanges; used to interpret how perceived HR inaction and organisational injustice disrupt the loyalty-for-security exchange, causing employees to withdraw effort and engagement.

References

  1. Abalkhail (2024).Qualitative study of employees in a Saudi healthcare organization documenting harmful leadership behaviors.

Source & Provenance

Reviewed by an editor
Publisher / Source

Not specified

Author

Megren Abdullah Altassan

Publication Date

August 3, 2026

Article Type

Research Study

Geography

Middle East

Content Type
Unknown Source Type
Original Source

Original source metadata is preserved. AI analysis is generated separately.

Like this? Get the Monday Decision Brief — free, every week.

No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Rate this article

Want the full article? Read it at the original source — free, no paywall.

Read original article
All content belongs to original publishers. AI analysis is for research purposes only. View original source