Editorial summary. This is our text summary of an article. We reached this item through a news aggregator and do not have a verified link to the publisher’s own page, so there is nowhere reliable to send you for the full text.
Peoplense's own analysis of this source, not the publisher's text. It was generated by machine from the source article and has not yet been read by one of our editors. Treat it as a starting point.
Editorial verdict
Credible academic findings with important caveats — the anchoring effect on manager ratings is well-evidenced, but the authors themselves acknowledge they cannot prove bias from the data alone; the race and gender disparities are real patterns that warrant scrutiny, not definitive proof of discriminatory intent.
Executive summary
This article reports on research co-authored by Iris Bohnet, Albert Pratt Professor of Business and Government at Harvard Kennedy School, examining how gender and race influence performance ratings at a multinational financial services company. The central argument is that sharing employee self-appraisals with managers prior to managerial review creates an 'anchoring' effect, where manager scores closely mirror self-ratings. The research finds that women and workers of color consistently rate themselves lower, with women of color assigning themselves the lowest self-ratings of any group. Managers, in turn, rated people of color more harshly than white employees, while showing a partial 'gender boost' that reduced — but did not eliminate — disadvantages for women. A system glitch that prevented managers from viewing self-appraisals in one year showed reduced correlation between self- and manager ratings, though racial and gender dynamics persisted, partly because managers appeared to reference prior-year self-evaluations. The authors conclude that demographic patterns in ratings are sufficiently correlated with social identity to raise concerns, even absent definitive proof of bias, and the company subsequently ceased sharing self-evaluations with managers prior to review.
Key insights
- 1Women and workers of color systematically assign themselves lower self-ratings, with women of color rating themselves the lowest of any demographic group studied.
- 2Manager ratings exhibit a strong 'anchoring' effect when managers view employee self-appraisals beforehand — scores closely correlate with those self-ratings, embedding pre-existing self-evaluation gaps into official performance records.
- 3Even when the anchoring mechanism was disrupted by a system glitch, racial and gender disparities in manager ratings persisted, partly because managers reverted to prior-year self-evaluations as a reference point.
Practical takeaways
- Organizations that allow managers to view employee self-appraisals before submitting their own ratings may be inadvertently encoding demographic disparities into official performance outcomes.
- Data analysis of internal performance rating patterns — disaggregated by gender, race, and employee tenure — can serve as a diagnostic tool for identifying potential inequities in appraisal systems.
Source & Provenance
Not specified
Not specified
December 10, 2025
Research Study
Global
Original source metadata is preserved. AI analysis is generated separately.
Like this? Get the Monday Decision Brief — free, every week.
No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

